Fired missiles can be evaded by hard maneuvers. Infra Red missiles’ lock on can be defeated if the targeted aircraft fly out of the missile seeker’s field of view.
According to industry expert for Smart Weapons and Unmanned Vehicle Systems, Debajit Sarkar, With radar guided missiles, it is possible to avoid or break radar lock (“Beam Turn” and “Doppler Turn”) by adopting hard turns that will cause the missile to lose the lock and consequently miss the target .
While fighter aircrafts will not face problems in adopting the evasive maneuvers we are talking here about a behemoth that has a max takeoff weight of 660,000 lbs, a wing span of 200 ft and an overall length of 242 ft. The pilot would have < 40 sec to make a hard maneuver even if he was aware that the aircraft was being targeted.
The 9M38M1 missile carries a 70Kg HE fragmentation warhead with a radar proximity fuse. Radar lock can be prevented or delayed through Jamming.
Large military aircrafts like the C-17 carries the AN/AAQ-24 Directional Infrared Counter Measures (DIRCM) system to protect the aircraft from IR missiles. These DIRCM systems do not come cheap.
One way to intercept ARH or IR missiles is to shoot them down with a Close in Weapon System (CIWS) like Phalanx. However, as on this date a miniaturized civilian version of a CIWS that can be used on Commercial Jet liners do not exist.
BUK M2 is a modern capable missile system designed to be used against small nimble fighter aircrafts that use Electronic Counter Measures (ECM). For a system like the BUK having active radar homing (ARH) seekers is same as for the Surface to Air Missile (SAM) system as it would for an aircraft using ARH R-77s instead of Semi-ARH R-27s.
Another advantage of vertical launch as in BUK is engagement time. With ARH missiles there is less need to continue tracking. It is certainly possible for ARH missiles to be used together with SARH missiles, and under some conditions using an ARH in a SARH mode makes sense too as the enormous radar on a TEL is going be more sophisticated and capable and have better ECCM capability against certain targets than the little radar set in the nose of a missile.
Flares and chaffs that a few Commercial Jet liners carry are useful only against old MANPADS. They are not effective against more modern MANPADs with 2-3 light spectrum filtration that can differ from decoys and actual engines.
Flares have zero effect on radar guided missiles. BUK-M2 consists of 3 vehicles. The TELAR BUK with the missiles, a command vehicle that passes the data feed and a radar vehicle that is usually located far away from the missile launcher. Depending on the position of BUK missile launcher and the radar it is fair to suggest that there is low probability of Chaffs being able to fool the System.
What Could Have Been Done to Avoid This Tragedy?
A good solution is not to fly over a No-Fly Zone. British Airways is avoiding Ukrainian airspace like plague as are a few other airliners.
The best thing a civilian airliner can do is to stick to commercial flight paths and keep its civilian transponder on. If it starts popping chaff and flares and trying to jam the system that will likely just confirm to the SAM crew the target is military and they would likely switch to optical guidance against which flares, jammers, chaff, etc are all useless.
The unfortunate part here is that MH-17 flew over this exact Ukrainian airspace many times in the past few weeks as FlightRadar24 confirms.
And even on July-17 MH-17 was not descending from 35000 ft. It flew over Poland at 31 000 ft, then climbed to 33000 ft when it entered Ukrainian airspace and stayed at that altitude before it was shot down.
So it was not that the aircraft descended from 35,000 ft to 32,000 ft thereby giving an impression to the BUK operators that it was a Military aircraft.
The article is a response by one of our readers on social media, Debajit Sarkar , a subject matter expert for Smart Weapons and Unmanned Vehicle Systems.
On 2 September 2009, DCNS signed a contract to supply and install torpedo countermeasures for the French Navy’s entire submarine fleet. This new success further strengthens the Group’s international standing as a world leader in underwater weapons
The French defence procurement agency (DGA) has awarded DCNS, Thales and ECA a major study contract that is expected to lead, around 2011, to a demonstrator of a new mine countermeasures solution dubbed ESPADON (Évaluation de Solutions Potentielles d'Automatisation de Déminage pour les Opérations Navales, or evaluation of potential solutions for the automation of mine clearing for naval operations.)
The Defence Science and Technology Agency (DSTA) of Singapore awarded Thales with the Life Extension Programme (LEP) of its 4 Bedok class mine-countermeasure vessels. Thales will provide an advanced, integrated mine-countermeasure (MCM) Combat System, including the Mine Information System, a Hull Mounted Sonar, a Towed Synthetic Aperture Sonar (SAS) and Expendable Mine Disposal Systems
ROLLING MEADOWS, Ill. --- Northrop Grumman Corporation has been awarded separate contracts to outfit U
NEWTOWN, Conn. --- Forecast International projects that the U
Saab starts serial production of the BOL countermeasures dispenser system for the Royal Australian Air Forces F-18 Hornet. The order is worth approximately 69 million SEK (10
Russia has denied using Buk missile in the Malaysian MH17 flight crash that happened last summer and says that it was done by the missile in possession of Ukrainian troops within three-four kilometres area. The official report however have concluded that Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 was shot down by a Russian-made BUK missile fired from rebel-held eastern Ukraine
Malaysian Defense Minister, Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Tun Hussein announced today that RM9.3 billion (US$2
Malaysian Sukhoi-30MKM fighter jets will soon be armed with Russian missiles, Ria Novosti reported Tuesday. The missiles will be manufactured by Irkut Corporation
Malaysia is planning to buy two variants of C28A Chinese warships for its navy, a local defense media website quoted industry sources as saying last week. “The deal for the two warships was supposed to be signed during the Prime Ministers visit to China last year during 40th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the two countries – but was cancelled at the last moment due to various issues, one of them was funding concerns
Rafale is looking at widening areas of collaborations with Malaysian partners during LIMA exhibition 2015. Rafale announced Monday that it is showcasing its two seater and single seater fighter aircraft during the expo
The likes of Boeing, Dassault, Eurofighter and Saab assembled at LIMA 2015 may come away disappointed as it is almost certain now that Kuala Lumpur may not consider an outright purchase to replace its MiG-29N fighters. Instead, a lease option has been mooted but its acceptance may depend upon the cost and terms of lease
Czech Republic Signs Iron Dome Deal
Australian C-130J LAIRCM Achieves Final Operational Capability
Saab Delivers Mobile Maintenance Facility to Hungarian Air Force
Lockheed to Equip Spanish F-110 Frigates with Solid State Radars
Airman falls from USAF C-130 While Training Over Gulf of Mexico: Reports
Russia to Lease New Military Airbase in Syria
AW101 Helicopter Crashes on top of Italian Battleship Deck
Germany To Finalise Order for 38 Eurofighter Jets, 110 E-Scan Radars
Several joint production and direct procurement programs could be halted if the US and Europe carry through with their threat...
Sanctions-hit Iran has found ingenious ways to develop military hardware
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly permeating the defence industry to aid and improve human decision-making
Upgrade of Russias Sukhoi Su-30SM fighters to equip them with armaments, radar, sensors and engines from the more powerful Su-35...
US companies sanctioned by China for supplying weapons to Taiwan may be denied rare earth elements (REEs), which have critical...
While the US F-35 stealth aircraft has become one the fastest selling fighter jets in the world aircraft market, thanks...