The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has reversed a decision in a patent suit against the US centering on the helmet-mounted display system (HMDS) in a fighter jet.
The Federal Circuit reversed the US Court of Federal Claims’ decision that US patent number 6,474,159 was unpatentable because of ineligible subject matter, World IP Review reported Thursday.
The ‘159 patent is owned by Thales Visionix, a developer of HMDS and motion tracking technology for defence and aerospace applications. It relates to an “inertial tracking system for tracking the motion of an object relative to a moving reference frame”.
Thales sued the US government, alleging that the HDMS in the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter infringed the patent. Elbit Systems, the government subcontractor that produces the HMDS, joined the case as a third-party defendant.
The government and Elbit moved for judgment on the pleadings, alleging that all asserted claims disclosed patent-ineligible subject matter under 35 USC section 101 because they claim a law of nature.
The Federal Claims court agreed, granting the motion for judgment and holding that all claims were directed to patent-ineligible subject matter.
In its decision, the court found that the claims were directed to the abstract idea of using laws of nature governing motion to track two objects, and provide no inventive concept beyond the abstract idea. Thales appealed to the Federal Circuit.
The court followed Alice v CLS Bank, explaining that the US Supreme Court’s two-part Alice framework guides courts in distinguishing between patent claims that “impermissibly claim the ‘building blocks of human ingenuity’ and those that ‘integrate the building blocks into something more’”
It held that the claims of the ‘159 patent were not directed to an abstract idea as they specify a particular configuration of inertial sensors and a particular method of using the raw data from the sensors.
“Because we find the claims are not directed to an abstract idea, we need not proceed to step two [of Alice],” said the court. The Federal Circuit reversed the court’s determination and remanded the lawsuit.
Thales has started testing and validation of the Aireon space-based Automatic Dependent Surveillance – Broadcast (ADS-B) data. The data validation started initially after signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) in June of 2015
Thales has been selected by UAE to develop capabilities in the fields of electronic warfare, anti-submarine warfare and security at NAVDEX 2017. Thaless has delivered onboard the first of class, dedicated to the Critical Infrastructure and Coastal Protection Authority (CICPA)
Indias Bharat Dynamics Limited (BDL) has signed a Memorandum of Understanding with Thales to assess the opportunity for the transfer of technology of the STARStreak missile capability to India with the support of United Kingdom (UK). The MoU was signed in the presence of Ms Harriet Baldwin, MP, Minister for Defence Procurement for the UK Government at Aero India 2017, Thales announced today
Thales has won a 74 million Euros contract to modernize Master radars over a period of 60 months for Swiss Air Force as part of the FLORAKO program. This contract will be the main order within the broader FLORAKO radars life extension project approved by the Swiss government in 2016, the company announced Wednesday
Thales has inaugurated a Cyberlab that allows the networks and information systems of businesses and public bodies to be prepared for cyberattacks. Also the centre is useful to educate students and enhance the training of cybersecurity specialists, the company announced Thursday
Thales has acquired a real-time Big Data analytics provider, Guavus, under a definitive agreement announced today. The acquisition of Guavus follows several acquisitions in the fields of connectivity, mobility and cyber security, and strengthens Thales's positioning in one of the key technologies at the heart of digital transformation, the processing and predictive analysis of “big data”, an increasingly critical factor in real-time decision-making, the company press release says
Indias Hindustan Aeronautics (HAL) will be ready to launch by July or August this year. The state-owned aerospace and defense company will wait for the results of the past financial year that are to be audited
Indias Hindustan Aeronautics (HAL) has finalized a plan to manufacture nearly 1000 military helicopters and over 100 planes. "We are going to build around 1,000 helicopters including Kamov 226, LCH (Light Combat Helicopter) ALH (Advanced Light Helicopter) in the next 10 years," HAL Chairman and Managing Director T Suvarna Raju told PTI in an interview
Elbit Systems has been awarded a $49 million worth contract to provide 126 helmet display tracker systems (HDTS) for the US Navy on the MH-60 aircraft. “Elbit Systems of America, Fort Worth, Texas, is being awarded a $49,884,371 firm-fixed-price, indefinite-delivery/indefinite-quantity contract for a maximum quantity of 126 helmet display tracker systems (HDTS) and associated line items for the Navy on the MH-60 aircraft,” the US Department of defense announced Wednesday
Russia To Soon Test MC-21 Jet Powered By PD-14 Engine
Denmark to Integrate Kongsberg's Protector RWS On Piranha Military Vehicles
California to get three S-70i FIREHAWKS
Russian "Spy" Ship Receives Panama Canal Permit Following Brief Blockade
Germany To Finalise Order for 38 Eurofighter Jets, 110 E-Scan Radars
Turkish Navy to get First Indigenous Aircraft Carrier in 2020
Bechtel Bags US Navy's $1.4Bn Naval Nuclear Propulsion Components Contract
Indian Air Force to Buy 83 Tejas Jets by March 2020
Several joint production and direct procurement programs could be halted if the US and Europe carry through with their threat...
Sanctions-hit Iran has found ingenious ways to develop military hardware
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly permeating the defence industry to aid and improve human decision-making
Upgrade of Russias Sukhoi Su-30SM fighters to equip them with armaments, radar, sensors and engines from the more powerful Su-35...
US companies sanctioned by China for supplying weapons to Taiwan may be denied rare earth elements (REEs), which have critical...
While the US F-35 stealth aircraft has become one the fastest selling fighter jets in the world aircraft market, thanks...